Advertisement 1

Precarious oil prices could complicate Bank of Canada's rate decision

Joe Chidley: Crude inventory numbers should have buoyed oil markets, but pessimism seems to have set in. And not without reason

Article content

During a media interview on June 13, Bank of Canada governor Stephen Poloz seemed pretty confident that things were looking up. The Canadian economy is gathering momentum, he suggested; two successive interest rate cuts in early 2015 had (maybe) “done their job,” and the November 2014 oil price shock was fading into memory.

And why wouldn’t he be confident? After years of what Poloz once called “serial disappointment,” GDP growth had just come in at a whopping 3.7 per cent for the first quarter, and oil prices had seemed to stabilize. Likewise, capital investment in the energy sector had picked up — a big factor in rising GDP. As Bank of Canada senior deputy governor Carolyn Wilkins said in a speech in Winnipeg the day before, “the adjustment to lower oil prices is now largely behind us.”

Advertisement 2
Story continues below
Article content

Taken together, markets considered Poloz’s and Wilkins’s statements as unusually bullish for the economy and hawkish for rates. The Canadian dollar responded, by rising, and investors dutifully updated expectations for a rate hike, giving about 50-50 odds for a boost at the Bank of Canada’s next meeting, on July 12.

Article content

And then, well, er, um… about that oil shock…

And about those rate expectations. Turns out it might be time for a rethink

On Tuesday, benchmark West Texas intermediate crude wandered into technical bear territory, dropping to near US$43 a barrel — a 22-per-cent decline from the 52-week high hit in January. It fell further Wednesday, by another two per cent, despite news from the U.S. Energy Information Administration that showed crude inventories had declined more than expected.

That inventory number should have buoyed oil markets, but pessimism seems to have set in. And not without reason.

It comes down to supply and demand.

On the demand side, the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) and some others express official optimism that a resurgent global economy will offset the supply glut. But the evidence for that demand renaissance has a few holes in it.

Article content
Advertisement 3
Story continues below
Article content

In Japan, the world’s fourth largest oil consumer, imports fell by 13.5 per cent last month, but that’s consistent with the long-term trend: according to the EIA, demand has fallen by nearly one-quarter over the past decade.

In the United States, the expected warm-season surge in gasoline demand has failed to materialize, and the EIA predicts total petrol consumption growth this year will be basically flat.

China — the world’s biggest net importer — has a big supply problem of its own. Gasoline and diesel reserves are so high that some of the country’s biggest refineries are poised to shut down for the entire third quarter, amounting to about 10 per cent of China’s total refining capacity, according to Reuters. That doesn’t bode well for resurgent global demand, at least not this year.

On the supply side, the North American shale industry has continued to grow at the expense of OPEC. Simply put, OPEC’s production cuts have led to prices that, while low, are still high enough to keep U.S. and Canadian tight-oil producers solvent. According to oilfield services company Baker Hughes, the number of rigs in the U.S. increased to 1,092 during the week ended June 16, marking the 22nd week in a row that the rig count has risen. In Canada, meanwhile, Baker Hughes reported an increase to 159 rigs — 2.3 times the number at the same time last year.

Advertisement 4
Story continues below
Article content

Meanwhile, Libya and Nigeria — two OPEC countries exempt from the production cuts because they’re grappling with de facto civil wars — have got their act together enough to ramp up production. So has Iraq. As a result, overall OPEC output in May — the same month the cartel agreed to renew its caps — rose by more than 330,000 barrels a day.

Recommended from Editorial
  1. Oil is set for its largest price slide in the first half of any year for the past two decades.
    Oil just dropped below $43 in its worst first half in two decades
  2. Traders now say there is a 50 per cent chance Stephen Poloz and the Bank of Canada will hike rates in July.
    Why does the Bank of Canada suddenly seem in such a hurry to hike rates?

And then, finally, there’s the question of what OPEC does next spring when its latest production agreement — which isn’t working to establish a price floor in the low $50s — ends next year. Will it renew? Or will it open the taps to try to gain back market share, savaging prices once again?

So let’s put it this way: the Canadian economy might have put one oil shock behind it, but that doesn’t mean another one isn’t on the way.

If that happens, the central bank would have 50 basis points less room to cut than it did in early 2015. If it cut anyway, then it would only be throwing gasoline (we have lots of it, anyway) on already overheated regional housing markets in Vancouver and Toronto. You also might want to wonder how much another 25 bps off the overnight rate would do to spur business investment, especially in the oil patch, if crude sinks again below US$30 a barrel.

Right now, the Bank of Canada’s biggest friend might be the weak loonie, which has been sinking this week right along with oil prices. That, at least, should encourage the “broadening” of our economy away from energy, as the Bank has been hoping for several years now. If it hikes in July, as some expect, that dividend evaporates.

In short, neither oil prices nor the Canadian economy is out of the woods yet. So we probably shouldn’t count too much on the Bank of Canada moving anytime soon from its preferred position: on the sidelines.

Article content
Comments
You must be logged in to join the discussion or read more comments.
Join the Conversation

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion. Please keep comments relevant and respectful. Comments may take up to an hour to appear on the site. You will receive an email if there is a reply to your comment, an update to a thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information.

This Week in Flyers